The new Pope Leo XIV, Robert Prevost, publicly criticized the current Vice President of the United States, JD Vance, last February for his statements regarding the hierarchy of Christian love, which is already being interpreted as a clear indication of his critical stance against the Trump agenda.
Prevost, then a bishop and an influential figure within the progressive wing of the U.S. Catholic Church, shared on his X account (formerly Twitter) an article from the National Catholic Reporter titled: “JD Vance is wrong: Jesus doesn't ask us to prioritize our love for others,” written by theologian Kat Armas.
Although no comments were added, the post was read as a firm stance against the statements made by the vice president and, in particular, against Donald Trump's immigration policy, which would make him feel uncomfortable.
The article was in response to comments made by Vance on Fox News, where he stated that "there is a Christian order of love" that prioritizes family first, then neighbors, and finally the rest of the world, and he accused "the extreme left" of reversing that supposed order.
Armas refuted the vice president's view, describing it as a medieval interpretation that perpetuates exclusive hierarchies and contradicts the logic of abundance and universality of the evangelical message.
"Jesus never speaks of love as something to be rationed, but rather as a table with room for everyone," wrote Armas, in a critique that resonated with Prevost, now the leader of more than a billion Catholics.
The election of León XIV is interpreted as a continuation of Pope Francis's pontificate, with a strong emphasis on social justice, welcoming migrants, and denouncing structures of exclusion. His appointment occurs at a pivotal political moment, as President Trump has been re-elected and his administration upholds a conservative agenda on issues such as immigration and religion.
It is worth noting that JD Vance was the last international leader to meet with Pope Francis before his passing on April 21. Now, with León XIV in the Vatican, a more tense relationship is anticipated between the Holy See and the U.S. administration.
The evening before, both Vance and Donald Trump celebrated the election of the first American pope in history, claiming it was a great source of pride.
Frequently asked questions about Pope Leo XIV and his relationship with the United States
Who is León XIV and what is his stance on the United States government?
León XIV, formerly known as Robert Francis Prevost, is the first American Pope and has taken a critical stance toward the United States government, especially regarding Donald Trump's agenda. Before becoming Pope, he publicly criticized Vice President JD Vance for his comments on the hierarchy of Christian love, emphasizing his disagreement with the conservative policies of the U.S. government.
What does the election of an American Pope mean for the Catholic Church and the United States?
The election of Leon XIV marks a milestone as the first Pope born in the United States, highlighting America's growing influence in the Catholic Church. For the United States, it represents a significant diplomatic dimension and a symbol of cultural diversity within the Church. Furthermore, his election reinforces the continuity of the focus on social justice and the welcoming of migrants that characterized Pope Francis.
What was Donald Trump's reaction to the election of Leo XIV as Pope?
The president Donald Trump expressed enthusiasm and congratulated the new Pope Leo XIV, highlighting the honor of having the first American Pope. However, relations between the Vatican and the Trump administration could be tense due to differences in their political agendas, particularly on issues of immigration and social justice.
What challenges does Pope Leo XIV face in his relationship with the U.S. administration?
Pope Leo XIV faces the challenge of maintaining a diplomatic relationship while upholding his criticisms of the conservative policies of the Trump administration. Leo XIV's election occurs in a context of reassessment of immigration and religious policies by the U.S. government, which could lead to additional tensions.
Filed under:
